Menu of Haydens Crossing in Wilmington, Illinois, USA

Menu Overview

Haydens Crossing, nestled in the heart of Wilmington, Illinois, delivers a classic steakhouse experience with a welcoming, rustic charm. This hidden gem at 107 N Water St offers more than just a place to eat—it serves memorable meals crafted with care and a nod to traditional flavors.

The menu features a variety of hearty options, but the true highlights lie in their steaks and pub-style offerings. The Delmonico Ribeye 14oz stands out as a centerpiece, promising tender, well-seasoned meat that steak lovers crave. For those who prefer sandwiches, the Ribeye Steak Sandwich offers a generously sized portion, packed with rich, juicy flavor that garners consistent praise for its satisfying heft.

Burgers at Haydens Crossing command attention. The Black & Bleu Burger with its blackened patty and crumbled Bleu cheese delivers a bold, smoky punch, balancing the sharpness of the cheese with the savory beef. Alternatively, the Southwest Burger layers pepper jack cheese, fresh guacamole, and pico de gallo on toasted sourdough, creating a vibrant southwestern flavor profile that complements the juicy patty beautifully. Their pub burger, classic and straightforward, offers customization with cheese and bacon additions, ensuring a burger to fit every palate.

The assorted salads bring a fresh, lighter option without sacrificing taste or texture. The Black & Bleu Salad and the Caesar Salad provide familiar, well-executed choices, while the Border Salad introduces a refreshing Mexican-inspired zest with chicken tinga and black bean corn salsa over crunchy tortilla chips. The option to add proteins like shrimp or salmon further elevates the vibrant salad offerings.

For wings lovers, Haydens Crossing serves some seriously flavorful selections. The Chicken Wings come in variations like traditional Buffalo or the especially enticing Thai Chili Glazed—they are large, well-seasoned, and perfect for sharing or savoring solo. Sides like the Loaded Potato Wedges are a standout, crispy and generously topped, pairing perfectly with beer selections such as Corona Light or signature cocktails like the Martini and Peach Razz.

The dessert menu isn’t overlooked either. The Strawberry Shortcake is a delightful finish—a sweet, airy treat that balances the meal’s savory heavyweights with fresh fruit and a light crumbly topping.

Customer feedback reflects the care put into the menu. Many praise the generous portion sizes and flavor depth, while highlighting that the atmosphere recreates a comfortable, Western saloon vibe. Service is generally friendly and attentive, which complements the dining experience, though occasional inconsistencies in steak doneness have been noted, indicating room for refinement.

Overall, Haydens Crossing offers a solid menu that satisfies steakhouse enthusiasts and pub food lovers alike. Its diverse offerings—from hand-packed burgers to expertly grilled steaks and flavorful wings—make it a dependable destination for those seeking hearty, thoughtfully prepared fare in a relaxed setting. Whether you're stopping in for a casual drink or a full steak dinner, this Wilmington staple is well worth discovering.